In today’s challenging real estate market, where home affordability has reached unprecedented lows, first-time homebuyers face significant hurdles in finding properties that align with their budgets. However, a recent study by personal finance website WalletHub sheds light on cities that offer better prospects for those embarking on their homeownership journey.

The study meticulously examined 22 key variables crucial to first-time buyers, including affordability, listing availability, quality of life factors (such as weather conditions and driver-friendliness), cost of living, real estate taxes, home insurance rates, and crime statistics. The results reveal some unexpected findings that may surprise many prospective homeowners.

Florida: An Unexpected Haven for First-Time Buyers

Surprisingly, Florida emerged as a top contender, with Palm Bay clinching the number one spot for first-time homebuyers. In fact, the Sunshine State dominated the top five rankings, despite its reputation for high insurance rates and extreme weather conditions.

However, it’s essential to note that WalletHub’s methodology focused on specific weather events like hail and tornadoes, overlooking other significant factors such as hurricanes, flooding, and intense heat. Joel Berner, a senior economist at Realtor.com®, points out that this approach “ignores some risks and overstates some qualities of these markets.”

The Importance of Expanding Your Search

While Florida may not be everyone’s ideal destination, the study underscores the importance of broadening one’s search in today’s competitive market. This is particularly relevant given that only 32% of homebuyers in the previous year were first-time purchasers, a significant drop from the historical average of 40%.

Cassandra Happe, an analyst at WalletHub, emphasizes the challenges faced by first-time buyers, stating, “Buying a home for the first time is a very stressful and difficult process, especially when housing prices are through the roof and interest rates have risen sharply in the past few years.”

Key Factors for First-Time Homebuyers to Consider

Mike Mei, an assistant professor at Colgate University, outlines several crucial factors that first-time homebuyers should take into account:

– Neighborhood density

– Proximity to retail and employment centers

– Public school quality

– Public safety

– Commute time

Mei particularly emphasizes the importance of considering commute times, noting that many people underestimate the negative impact of long commutes on their quality of life. He states, “Many people underestimate the negative effect of long commutes on the quality of life. They trade longer commutes for a larger or less expensive home. However, a large amount of economic and health research has shown that long commutes significantly harm health and happiness.”

Get your free guide “Passive Real Estate Investing For Busy Professionals”

Top 10 Cities for First-Time Homebuyers

1. Palm Bay, FL

Median List Price: $349,999

Palm Bay tops the list, boasting the third-highest millennial homeownership rate in the nation. With the fourth-highest home appreciation rate and a wealth of both new and older home listings, Palm Bay presents numerous options for first-time buyers. New housing developments are prevalent, offering homes at a median price of $200 per square foot, making this city highly attractive.

2. Cape Coral, FL

Median List Price: $455,000

Located on Florida’s west coast, Cape Coral is less prone to hurricanes compared to the Atlantic side of the state. It features a high number of home listings and new building permits per capita. The city also has a low crime rate and ranks ninth for its school system, providing a safe and educational environment for families.

3. Port St. Lucie, FL

Median List Price: $445,000

Port St. Lucie has the second-highest millennial homeownership rate and ranks impressively low in property and violent crime rates. With strong home price appreciation and a median price of $261 per square foot, this city remains affordable for new buyers. The area’s robust growth and low crime make it a desirable place to invest.

4. Tampa, FL

Median List Price: $475,000

As the largest city on this list, Tampa ranks first in quality of life. It offers a plethora of outdoor activities, professional sports, and cultural attractions. Although it’s less affordable (ranked 177 out of 300), the high number of home listings and vibrant lifestyle make Tampa a top choice for first-time buyers.

5. Orlando, FL

Median List Price: $399,999

Orlando is known for its famous theme parks and diverse entertainment options. Despite its big-city perks, it ranks fifth in affordability and boasts a low crime rate. The high number of active listings makes Orlando a competitive market for new homebuyers.

6. Surprise, AZ

Median List Price: $474,250

This desert community is known for its spring training facilities and growing arts scene. With a population of 155,000, it ranks fourth in real estate market metrics. Surprise offers a balanced mix of affordability, quality of life, and a strong real estate market.

7. Lakeland, FL

Median List Price: $350,000

Lakeland’s historical charm and proximity to Tampa make it a great choice for first-time buyers. The city is ninth in quality of life, featuring many lakes and historic sites. Its affordable housing and reasonable commute times to Tampa add to its appeal.

8. Boise, ID

Median List Price: $569,000

Known for its state university and outdoor amenities, Boise offers a high quality of life. With a median list price of $312 per square foot, it’s more expensive than other cities on this list but provides a stable real estate market free from extreme weather concerns.

9. Gilbert, AZ

Median List Price: $650,000

Gilbert appeals to young families with its top-ranked schools and median price of $293 per square foot. Its proximity to Phoenix and a thriving community atmosphere make it an attractive option despite higher costs.

10. Henderson, NV

Median List Price: $562,950

Henderson benefits from Nevada’s lack of state income tax and its proximity to Las Vegas. The city offers vibrant sports and entertainment options, and a median price of $286 per square foot makes it relatively affordable.

Click here to learn more and subscribe to the newsletter

The Worst Cities for First-Time Homebuyers

On the other end of the spectrum, the study identified cities that pose significant challenges for first-time buyers. These cities, while not necessarily undesirable places to live, rank low due to affordability issues, limited housing availability, and quality of life concerns such as traffic congestion, higher crime rates, and lower-rated public school systems.

The bottom 10 cities for first-time homebuyers are:

1. Berkeley, CA

2. Santa Monica, CA

3. Anchorage, AK

4. Santa Barbara, CA

5. Oakland, CA

6. San Francisco, CA

7. Los Angeles, CA

8. Glendale, CA

9. Costa Mesa, CA

10. New York, NY

It’s worth noting that California dominates this list, occupying 8 out of 10 spots, with New York City and Anchorage, Alaska, being the exceptions.

Conclusion

While the findings of this study may challenge some preconceived notions about ideal locations for first-time homebuyers, they underscore the importance of thorough research and consideration of multiple factors when making such a significant life decision. As the real estate market continues to evolve, prospective buyers must weigh various elements, from affordability and quality of life to long-term investment potential, to find the best fit for their needs and aspirations.

You can read the full article here.

Share this: