The idea of owning a private island sounds like the ultimate luxury—a personal paradise away from the chaos of everyday life. However, not all islands are dream investments. Some come with hidden legal battles, environmental hazards, difficult access, or strict regulations that make them more trouble than they’re worth. Here are seven private islands currently on the market that few buyers are willing to take on.

1. Point Buckler Island, California, USA

Located in the San Francisco Bay, Point Buckler Island spans 39 acres and has been the subject of intense legal and environmental disputes. The island’s owner faced fines and restoration mandates due to unauthorized development, leading to an uncertain future for potential buyers. Any new owner would need to navigate strict environmental regulations and costly rehabilitation efforts.

2. Punta Pennata, Italy

Nestled near Bacoli, Italy, Punta Pennata is listed for up to €10 million. However, its sale has sparked controversy, with local opposition to private ownership. Strict construction restrictions limit development, reducing its appeal for investors who might otherwise see potential in the Mediterranean retreat.

3. Vacsay Island, Scotland, UK

This 101-acre island in Scotland boasts stunning, unspoiled beaches, but its legal entanglements make ownership complicated. The land is subject to a long-term common grazing agreement, meaning private development is nearly impossible. Any buyer must contend with these traditional land-use rights, making it a difficult purchase for those hoping to create a secluded getaway.

Click here to learn more and subscribe to the newsletter

4. Timana Island, Queensland, Australia

Situated near the Great Barrier Reef, Timana Island covers 15 hectares and is almost entirely undeveloped, except for an old shack. While its proximity to one of the world’s most famous natural wonders is appealing, its remote location and lack of infrastructure make it a difficult investment. The high costs of developing utilities, transportation, and accommodations deter potential buyers.

5. Kaibu Island, Fiji

With an asking price of $79.5 million, Kaibu Island is a massive 800-acre resort island offering luxury amenities. However, despite its appeal as a tropical retreat, its high price tag and remote location have scared away potential buyers. Running and maintaining an island of this size in such a distant location requires significant resources and logistical planning.

6. North Island, Maldives

This Maldivian island, offered at £33.7 million, includes plans for a luxury villa. However, its steep price and the challenges of developing in a remote region have deterred investors. The Maldives’ strict environmental regulations and risks related to rising sea levels further complicate the appeal of this purchase.

7. SuperShe Island, Finland

Once marketed as an exclusive retreat for women, SuperShe Island in Finland was initially listed at £2.4 million but is now up for auction with bids starting from £800,000. Despite its uniqueness, its remote location and limited accessibility have resulted in little interest from potential buyers.

Get your free guide “Passive Real Estate Investing For Busy Professionals”

Why These Islands Struggle to Sell

Private islands may sound glamorous, but their ownership often comes with significant challenges:

Legal and Regulatory Hurdles: Many islands face land-use restrictions, environmental protection laws, and ownership disputes that can limit development potential.

High Maintenance Costs: Islands require infrastructure for water, electricity, waste management, and transportation, making them expensive to maintain.

Difficult Accessibility: Many of these islands lack easy transportation options, requiring boats, helicopters, or private jets to reach them.

Environmental Risks: Rising sea levels, hurricanes, and climate change threats make some islands less viable long-term investments.

Conclusion

Owning a private island may seem like a dream, but the reality is often far more complicated. While some islands are available for purchase, they come with significant drawbacks that deter even the wealthiest buyers. Whether due to legal entanglements, environmental hazards, or accessibility issues, these seven islands highlight why private island ownership is not always the paradise it appears to be.

Share this: