Renowned magician David Copperfield finds himself at the center of a legal battle that no illusion can easily resolve. The famed illusionist is being sued by the board of his Midtown Manhattan condominium for allegedly allowing his luxurious penthouse to fall into severe disrepair. The lawsuit, which seeks $2.5 million in damages, claims that Copperfield’s neglect has not only trashed his own apartment but also threatens the structural integrity of the entire building.

The Galleria condominium board’s lawsuit attributes much of the damage to Copperfield’s own negligence, pointing to specific incidents that have caused extensive damage. The first of these occurred in 2015 when the rooftop pool, allegedly outfitted with “illegal and ineffective” plastic plumbing, burst. The resulting flood sent torrents of water cascading down 30 floors, causing significant damage to numerous units in the building. This incident alone, the lawsuit alleges, caused enough damage to potentially compromise the building’s structural integrity.

Floods, Failures, and Legal Fights: Inside the Condo Board’s $2.5M Lawsuit

The situation worsened in December of last year when a valve failed in the then-abandoned penthouse, leading to yet another flood. This time, water poured into elevator shafts, hallways, and other condos, exacerbating the existing damage and further endangering the building’s infrastructure. The suit, filed in Manhattan Supreme Court, alleges that these incidents—and the lingering damage they caused—may have compromised the structural integrity of the 55-story luxury complex on East 57th Street.

According to the lawsuit, Copperfield’s abrupt departure from the building in 2018 was far from orderly. Instead of leaving in a responsible manner, the suit claims, Copperfield left his penthouse in a state of utter disrepair. Shocking photos attached to the legal filing reveal the extent of the damage: paint peeling from walls, collapsing ceilings, and floors stained beyond recognition. These images are presented as evidence of the apartment’s severe deterioration, which the board argues poses a threat to the entire building.

Architects brought in by the condominium board have issued warnings about the dangers posed by the unrepaired water damage in Copperfield’s apartment. The lawsuit states that the damage is so extensive that it could impact the “concrete structure of the building,” promote the growth of mold and mildew, and endanger other units within the complex.

Despite these serious allegations, the 67-year-old magician, who still maintains a long-running residency in Las Vegas and boasts a net worth approaching $1 billion, has reportedly refused to address the complaints. The lawsuit claims that Copperfield has made only minimal repairs to superficial issues while ignoring more critical problems that threaten the health and safety of his neighbors.

Get your free guide “Passive Real Estate Investing For Busy Professionals”

Why Won’t Copperfield Fix His Own Penthouse?

The motivation behind Copperfield’s alleged neglect remains unclear, especially given that he still owns the penthouse and has been marketing it for sale. The condo board’s attorney, Joshua Stricoff, remarked on Wednesday that the allegations and accompanying photographs “speak for themselves and don’t require any further elaboration.” Stricoff added that the board hopes Copperfield will eventually take responsibility and address the damage.

The lawsuit seeks at least $2.5 million in damages and demands that Copperfield repair the destruction caused by his alleged negligence. In response to the suit, a representative for Copperfield downplayed the situation, characterizing it as “a simple insurance claim.” The representative also claimed that the photographs included in the lawsuit do not reflect the current state of the apartment, asserting that the matter would be handled in court.

Copperfield purchased the 15,000 square-foot condo—a “formerly pristine multilevel penthouse apartment” with stunning views of Central Park and the Upper East Side—in 1997 for $7.4 million. Shortly after the purchase, he transferred ownership to a shell company he controls, according to the lawsuit. The penthouse, described by Curbed in 2016 as “a spaceship-like assemblage of glass levels,” was filled with an eclectic mix of unusual items, including a 100-year-old “surprise chair” with a trap bottom, antique arcade games, mannequins, an “exploding table,” and stairs that convert into a slide.

One neighbor, who has lived in the building since 1976, described Copperfield as a pleasant person based on a brief elevator encounter. However, he emphasized that Copperfield should take responsibility for the damage attributed to him, noting that in a condominium, “everybody is responsible for their own apartment.” While this neighbor’s unit was not affected by either flood, he expressed concern about the building’s overall condition, mentioning that maintenance staff estimated the repairs needed for the entire building could cost around $20 million.

Copperfield’s penthouse is so large that it requires its own mechanical equipment, separate from the heating, ventilation, electrical, and other utilities that service the rest of the building. The lawsuit claims that Copperfield was responsible for maintaining this equipment but failed to do so, leading to disastrous consequences.

The 2015 pool incident, for example, was allegedly caused by Copperfield’s use of “illegal and ineffective plastic plumbing fixtures” that eventually failed, resulting in the significant flood. The more recent flood on December 27, 2023, was attributed to a valve failure in the mechanical service room, which the condo board claims was partly due to Copperfield’s decision to fire his house manager, housekeeper, and handyman when he left the building in 2018.

The lawsuit accuses Copperfield of refusing to confront the consequences of his actions and denying responsibility for the damage caused to the building and his former neighbors. An architect who assessed the penthouse compiled a detailed report listing numerous issues, including water damage that compromised the building’s structural integrity, leaking skylights, mold and mildew, collapsing ceilings, unstable pipes, and inadequate gas protection, among other problems.

Click here to learn more and subscribe to the newsletter

The board sent this report to Copperfield’s attorney in March, but according to the lawsuit, their concerns were ignored. This is not the first time Copperfield has faced legal troubles. In May, he was accused of sexual misconduct by 16 women, some of whom claim they were underage or drugged at the time. Copperfield has denied these allegations, insisting that he has “never, ever acted inappropriately with anyone, let alone anyone underage.”

As the lawsuit progresses, it remains to be seen whether Copperfield will address the serious issues raised by the condo board or if the matter will be resolved in court. For now, the magician’s once-glamorous Midtown penthouse stands as a stark reminder that even the most skilled illusionists cannot make their problems simply disappear.

Share this: