Why would a historic residence associated with a former U.S. president sell so much less than its former price? Donald Trump’s boyhood home in New York should be a valued piece of presidential realty, but in an unexpected twist, the historic property was sold for only $835,000, a huge decrease over its 2017 price of $2.14 million.

What went wrong—and what can this reveal about real estate trends, foreclosed homes, and speculative buying risks? Let’s explore the interesting (and somewhat strange) history of this former celebrated Queens residence.

From Birthplace of Presidents to Neighborhood Eyesore

It was where Donald Trump resided until he was four years old, in this unassuming Tudor-style home at 85-15 Wareham Place in Queens. It was built in 1940 by Fred C. Trump, Donald’s father and noted realty developer, as a symbol of early success tales of Americans. But by 2024, it was a cautionary story.

Thus, how did a residence associated with a U.S. President plummet so low in terms of value?

1. Negligent Maintenance Made It a “Spook House”

Neighbors told it as it was: “abandoned,” “neglected,” and “infested with stray cats.” The home was vacant for years with no maintenance performed on it. The basement was destroyed by mold from a leaked water pipe, and the grass went uncut until locals stepped in to take care of it themselves.

Somewhere along the way, “vacate” and “water shut-off” notices were posted on the door, and inside had been reduced to bare studs. It wasn’t aging—it was falling apart.

Compare this to other historic houses, such as Barack Obama’s childhood home in Honolulu, a home preserved and cherished—not left to decay.

2. The Cats Took Over—Literally

Yes, a group of stray cats settled in and made their home there. Volunteers were said to feed them, but having wild animals residing on the property was not exactly going to increase its value.

This strange tidbit was a sign of the property’s abandonment. It also leaves you to wonder:

What occurs when old houses are left unkept? Even presidential ties are unable to protect a building from ruin—or stray animals.

Click here to learn more and subscribe to the newsletter

3. The Airbnb Gamble That Did Not Pay Off

A Chinese investor recently purchased the residence for more than $2 million in early 2017, shortly after Trump’s inauguration, through an LLC called “Trump Birth House.” The property was listed, albeit briefly, on Airbnb for $815 a night under the banner of a presidential experience—accompanied by plaques implying this was where Trump was possibly conceived.

Initially, it attracted worldwide interest, particularly among Chinese tourists who were impressed by Trump’s entrepreneurial accomplishment. Later, it lost momentum, and the glamour disappeared.

By 2021, the investor attempted to crowdfund $3 million to give away the house to Trump—but that effort failed too. The home was more of a novelty than a real asset by this point.

New Buyer, New Hope—or Another Flip?

Donald Trump’s childhood home’s new owner, a Brooklyn LLC named 1388 Group, paid just $835,000—a small fraction of its prior worth. With more than $930,000 in renovation funding from a lender of “fix and flip” deals, there’s no question this purchase was not motivated by sentiment. It was probably a business decision.

What’s going to happen with the house?

Construction workers are already gutting out the interior, piling debris into garbage containers with spray-painted tags on them. The owner, according to local residents, has a business strategy of flipping houses as soon as possible, instead of maintaining their original character. Where do we draw the line between profit and preservation when it comes to historic homes?

This case certainly tilts in favor of profit, but it also reveals a greater truth: realty isn’t so much about price as it’s about story behind walls. A property associated with a U.S. President can depreciate simply by being ignored or handled as just another asset.

Trump’s childhood dwelling sits at a crossroads today. Will it be restored with reverence—or flipped and neglected? Time will bear witness, but its path thus far has been an interesting case study in how celebrity loses its glow so quickly when in unthoughtful ownership.

Get your free guide “Passive Real Estate Investing For Busy Professionals”

A Real Estate Reality Check

This anecdote serves to underscore a very important point: even celebrated houses can become financial liabilities if neglected. History by itself isn’t enough to uphold a property’s worth.

Following are some lessons for investors and homeowners:

Negligence destroys value. Not even presidential affiliations can salvage a dilapidated building.

Speculative purchases are not a good idea. Trending doesn’t necessarily mean a long-term asset.

Novelties are temporary. Airbnb vacation rentals with a novelty tagline are only so trendy for so long.

Closing Comments: What will Happen to Trump’s Childhood Home?

No matter if its new owner decides to restore it with devotion or resell it to make a profit, there’s no denying this: this is more than a real-estate story—it’s a study in how history, decay, and market circumstance come together.

Trump’s childhood home became an eyesore in the neighborhood after a few short years as a tourist attraction. It proves that no esteemed past can save a property from depreciation if it’s not well maintained.

Ultimately, this story serves as a reminder that real estate involves more than walls and square footage—it’s about how we take care of the stories those walls contain. The future of this home undoubtedly remains uncertain, yet its course provides a revealing snapshot of speculative ownership’s risks and realities.

Share this: