Discover the pros and cons of new construction and existing property investments. Evaluate factors such as location, rental income, financing options, and long-term goals to make an informed real estate investment decision.


Choosing whether to invest in new construction versus an existing property can be a real head-scratcher. There are so many factors to weigh and analyze – it’s enough to make your head spin!


As a real estate investor myself, I’ve spent many a sleepless night mulling over this decision. Do I go for the shiny new build with all the modern bells and whistles? Or the tried-and-true older building with “good bones” (as we like to say)? There are compelling cases to be made for both options, so let’s break it down.



Evaluating the Pros and Cons


When looking at new construction versus existing, each has its own unique set of advantages and disadvantages. Let’s take a deeper dive:


New Construction Pros


Brand new amenities and features – we’re talking granite countertops, luxury vinyl plank floors, walk-in closets…the works! Tenants go ga-ga over new and improved.


Less maintenance and repairs (initially, at least). I’m smiling just thinking about the lack of leaky faucets and finicky appliances in a new build.


Energy efficiency – new buildings must meet stringent codes for insulation, windows, HVAC. Saving on utilities is music to my ears!


Customization options – build it your way, with the exact layouts and finishes you want. My buddy James crafted his dream duplex with a rooftop lounging deck.


Potential for higher rents – people will pay a premium for that new construction smell. Market it right and you could be raking in the dough!


New Construction Cons


Higher upfront costs – between materials, labor, permits, it adds up quickly. You’ll need solid financing. My friend Ella put 40% down on her new 4-unit – a hefty chunk of change!


Unknowns lurking – faulty plumbing, cracks in the foundation…defects can emerge over time and leave you with pricy repairs. Fingers crossed that warranty has you covered!


Often located further from amenities – new developments may be in up-and-coming outskirts without easy access yet to attractions renters want.


Limited history – no track record of appreciation or rental demand. It’s all speculative until the market responds.


Existing Property Pros


Lower purchase costs – you skip the new construction premium and buy at market rate. I scored a great deal on a fixer-upper near downtown.


Established neighborhoods – mature areas with grocery stores, parks, transit – the infrastructure renters want. Accessibility is a major perk!


Appreciation history – for existing properties, you can look to past sales for value growth trends. Helpful for projecting future gains.


Vintage charm – older buildings offer architectural details and character you can’t easily replicate. Tenants will swoon over that original tile work!


Existing Property Cons


Unknown conditions – inspections help, but won’t uncover every foundation crack, leaky pipe, or faulty wiring lurking within the walls. Be prepared for surprises!


Dated finishes need updating – that Harvest Gold toilet has got to go! Upgrading can get expensive, but is often necessary to attract tenants.


Pre-wear and tear – fixing others’ damage from over the years isn’t fun. But with some blood, sweat, and cash, you can turn things around.


Prior stigmas – bad reputations are hard to shake. If the property had troubled tenants or lapsed maintenance, it may take effort to rebrand.


As you can see, the pros and cons balance out in many ways. There’s no universally “right” option – you’ve got to consider your own investment goals.



Key Factors to Consider


Speaking of goals, let’s look at some of the key factors to weigh:


Location – For both new and existing properties, the site location impacts two things: long-term appreciation potential and rental demand. Being near amenities and attractions renters want generally commands higher rents and stronger value growth.


But you pay a premium upfront for these prime spots. It’s the age-old real estate conundrum – you’ve got to spend money to make money.


Financing – Construction loans tend to have higher rates/fees than conventional mortgages on existing builds. And you’ll likely need a heftier downpayment on a new build. Crunch the numbers to see if the debt service fits your budget.


Rental Income – Will brand new high-end finishes allow you to charge ultra-competitive rents? Or can you earn strong income from an existing building with vintage character in a trendy area? Study the local comparables to project potential.


Expenses – Existing properties come with more unknowns, like repairs and overhauls to dated systems. But ongoing maintenance and replacements are inevitable in any building, old or new. Budget wisely for both options.


Appreciation – In high-growth areas, new construction may enjoy a value pop initially. But existing properties also gain value from neighborhood improvements over time. Historical trends can indicate what to expect.


Tax Implications – Here’s where I call in reinforcements! Work with a qualified CPA to maximize tax deductions and credits that may vary between new versus existing investments. Don’t leave money on the table.



Developing the Right Strategy


To maximize your chosen investment over the long-term, tailor your strategy accordingly:


New Construction Strategy


– Act quickly to secure pre-construction purchases in promising growth areas. The early bird investment deals can be the juiciest!


– Thoroughly vet the builder – check reviews, confirm adequate warranty coverage, inspect model homes. Avoid corner cutting!


– Furnish and list units for rent ASAP once finished to start offsetting carrying costs. Market competitively to attract top tenant pool.


– Monitor operating expenses closely – track utility usage, maintenance needs. Keep service contracts on HVAC systems, appliances to protect warranty coverage.


Existing Property Strategy


– Seek properties with strong bones – good structure and infrastructure that won’t require full-scale overhauls ($$$). Minor updates go further.


– Prioritize investments in modern finishes and systems – kitchen, bath, windows, roofing. Curb appeal and functionality are key!


– Highlight vintage architectural details in marketing – preserve and accent original floors, railings, fireplaces. Lean into the old-world charm!


– Refinance to withdraw equity for renovations or additional acquisitions. Leverage gains to expand your portfolio.


No matter what type of investment you choose, stay actively engaged throughout ownership. Monitor local market shifts, keep up with routine maintenance, adjust your approach over time. The savvy investors consistently finetune their strategies to adapt.



Navigating the Financing Landscape


Speaking of savvy moves, securing favorable financing terms makes or breaks a real estate investment. Here are some tips and tricks to optimize the numbers:


New Construction Financing


Shop builders’ in-house lenders against banks and credit unions to find the best rates, fees and terms. A little competition can benefit you!


Negotiate allowances for design selections and upgrades within the construction loan budget. Get the finishes you want without overextending.


Discuss options to convert to permanent financing once completed – ask about streamlined approvals and limited fees to switch lenders.


Existing Property Financing


Comparison shop multiple mortgage lenders – local, regional, national, and online. Expand your search for ideal loan programs.


Prioritize lenders offering discounted rates/fees for investment properties. Ask about preferred investor benefits.


Consider mixing and matching financing – conventional mortgage plus HELOC for rehab funds. Layer according to unique needs.


Weigh pros and cons of adjustable-rate mortgages – lower initial payments but interest rate volatility over time. Run the numbers!


Remember – interest rates, fees, terms, and lender requirements constantly fluctuate. Regularly connect with your loan officer to discuss market changes and strategize your next move, whether refinancing existing holdings or financing future acquisitions.



The Taxman Cometh – Plan Accordingly!


Didn’t I say we’d need to chat taxes? When it comes to the old IRS, planning ahead is crucial to maximize write-offs and deductions.


For New Construction:


Cost segregation study – identify components with shorter depreciation schedules (roof, appliances, carpets) to accelerate write-offs.


Energy efficiency tax credits – tens of thousands back on Energy Star-certified builds. Cha-ching! Discuss qualifications with your CPA.


For Existing Properties:


Capital improvements – renovations, upgrades added to property basis for increased annual depreciation deductions.


Cost recovery deductions – deduct a portion of purchase price and improvements over time. Consult the tax manual for calculations!


Code updates for ADA compliance, fire safety – expenses may qualify you for tax credits and faster depreciation.


For Both:


– Keep immaculate records! Track purchases, operating expenses, improvements – proof is critical for supporting deductions.


– Consider a cost segregation study for identifying shorter-life components eligible for accelerated depreciation.


– Hire a savvy CPA experienced with rental properties. Initial fees can yield years of future tax savings. Worth it!


The intricacies of real estate tax law would make your head spin. Always work closely with a qualified tax pro to maximize benefits and avoid missteps.



Final Thoughts


As you can see, choosing between new construction versus buying an existing investment property is far from simple! There are so many variables to weigh from finances and taxes to long-term strategies.


My advice? Take your time and do your homework before taking the plunge. Connect with experts – loan officers, CPAs, management companies – to understand the full scope of benefits and obligations. Crunch the numbers for multiple scenarios – worst case, probable, best case. Only risk what you can afford to lose, just in case surprises pop up. Hey, I’ve learned that lesson myself – the hard way!

But most importantly, trust your instincts. You know your investment style and risk tolerance better than anyone. Align your decision with your overall financial goals and timeline. Real estate investing rarely goes just as planned. Expect some hiccups along the way. But armed with the right information and support team, you can navigate the challenges and ultimately prosper. Here’s to many happy years of returns ahead!


Disclaimer: The information provided in this blog post is for informational purposes only and should not be considered as financial or investment advice. Always conduct thorough research and consult with professionals before making any investment decisions.


Are you interested in learning more about multifamily real estate investing? Our team of experienced professionals is here to help. Whether you’re looking for advice on conducting market research or need assistance in identifying the best investment opportunities, we have the knowledge and expertise to guide you through the process. Connect with us today through our Telegram channel for real-time updates and valuable insights. Subscribe to our YouTube channel to access informative videos and expert discussions on multifamily real estate investing. Follow us on Instagram for inspiring visuals and exclusive content. Contact us now to schedule a consultation and take the first step towards achieving your financial goals in the multifamily real estate industry

Where to Listen: