For most people looking to own a house, that dream can be rather unreachable. For many markets, high housing prices, rising mortgage rates, and the less obvious upkeep fees have drastically driven up buying a starter home way beyond the more affordable choice compared to renting. Is renting always the deal, or are there certain trade-offs worth making? This article explores the top 10 markets where renting pays cheaper than buying, looking wider at what the broader trend may mean.

The Increasing Cost of Owning a Home

Owning a starter home in much of the country’s major metropolises carries a seriously outsized cost premium. The average single-family property costs $1,091 a month to buy compared with rents for a similar property today. That gap, narrowly smaller than last year and well above the historical-norm gap of $233, is one reason renter households have grown a combined 774,023 since 2016-along with other factors having to do with demographics that skew younger and less likely married. The last time owning appeared cheaper than renting was indeed back in 2016, and conditions haven’t improved since then.

This widening gap can be attributed to a combination of factors:

Soaring Home Prices: The continued limited inventory of housing is driving prices upwards.

High Mortgage Rates: Fixed 30-year mortgage rates are running at almost 7%, meaning the amount of monthly payments is growing substantially.

Maintenance Costs: Owning a home means paying more in property taxes, insurance, and maintenance, to which renters do not have to attend.

Affordability vs. Equity

While renting may be cheaper in the short term, it does not offer the financial benefits of building equity. Homeownership has long been a key driver of wealth creation in the United States. In 2022, the median net worth of homeowners in the U.S. was $400,000, while that of renters stood at just $10,400-a stark contrast which underlines the long-term economic benefit of owning a home, even as initial costs remain steep.

Click here to learn more and subscribe to the newsletter

Top 10 Markets Where Renting Wins

Austin, TX: Austin renters save an average of $1,900 per month compared to people who purchase a home. The median rent in the city is $2,000, but the 89% purchase premium makes owning prohibitively expensive for many.

Denver, CO: $1,298 The estimated monthly savings for Denver renters. The median $1,850 rent well reflects the city’s expensive cost of owning with its 47% purchase premium.

Las Vegas, NV: Buying in Las Vegas is $1,287 more expensive per month than renting. At a $2,000 median rent, its 67% purchase premium continues to make renting more practical for many residents.

Riverside-San Bernardino, CA: In this area, renters save $1,207 per month with a median rent of $2,050. The 46% premium to purchase indicates that homeownership is not very affordable.

Phoenix, AZ: The average savings per month for renters in Phoenix is $1,176. The median rent of $1,700 along with the purchase premium of 59% makes buying out of range for many.

Dallas, TX: Dallas residents save $1,028 by renting. A median rent of $1,800 and a 41 percent purchase premium explains why people mostly rent in the location.

Nashville, TN: In Nashville, renters are saving $990 compared with buying. The $2,400 median rent in this city swells 46% with its purchase premium, adding financial stressors to homeownership.

Miami, FL: A person saves $915 a month by renting in Miami. The median rent in the city is $3,000, while the 28% premium to purchase reflects the high cost of living in the region.

Get your free guide “Passive Real Estate Investing For Busy Professionals”

Raleigh-Durham, NC: Homebuyers in Raleigh-Durham save $847 per month. The median rent is $1,600, while the median sales price carries a 42% premium over median rent.

Orlando, FL: Matching Raleigh-Durham, renters in Orlando save $847 a month. With the median rent standing at $2,100 against a purchase premium of 38%, rentals remain decidedly one of the financially reasonable options.

Why Renting is Cheaper

The gap between renting and buying is very large, primarily as high mortgage rates have raised payments considerably. To go back to historical norms of balance in the financial books, mortgage rates would have to drift downwards to about 3.75%, which is highly improbable in the near future. Furthermore, though some home builders have introduced rate buy-down programs in an effort to tempt buyers, those have also not bridged the chasm in affordability.

Strategies for Navigating the Market

For those priced out of being able to buy, there are ways to make the most of it. Relocation to cities where the difference in cost between renting and buying is small may be considered, such as Cincinnati, OH. One can also see what incentives homebuilders offer, including discounted mortgage rates, which might make purchasing more within reach. And finally, renters can begin building a down payment pool with their monthly savings to prepare for eventual homeownership when conditions improve.

Conclusion

Whether to rent or buy depends upon an individual’s financial status and long-term goals. In today’s market, as in the given 10 cities, savings through renting are high, but homeownership is hard to beat for building wealth. As the housing market adapts, being knowledgeable, adaptable, and open becomes a vital component in such decisions that enable you to make the choice that precisely meets your future needs and wants.

Share this: