Ever wonder who has the largest property tax bills in New York City – and why? The answer not just includes staggering dollar figures but also reveals deeper issues with the city’s tax system, real estate market, and economic inequality. In this piece, we’re exploring the top property tax bill homes, their owners, and what it reveals about life – and luxury – in the city.

NYC’s Biggest Property Tax Bills: Who’s Paying the Most?

Billionaire hedge fund manager Ken Griffin is paying more in a year’s worth of property taxes on his ultra-high-end penthouse than most New Yorkers will pay on a home in their lives. Griffin must pay over $860,000 in property tax for the 2024–2025 tax year on his home at 220 Central Park South – one of the most elite addresses on the globe.

But he’s not even on the top of the list.

That title belongs to Qatar’s former Emir, whose massive compound on East 72nd Street has taxed out at a staggering $984,000 this year. Those two payments combined could pay for dozens of public school teachers’ salaries or fix city infrastructure — a testament to how lopsidedly skewed NYC’s real estate value is.

Why Are These Tax Bills So High?

Does luxury living correlate with a higher property tax? Absolutely. New York City’s property tax bills are directly correlated with property values. So, if you’re residing in a $200+ million penthouse overlooking Central Park, you’re obviously going to have bigger tax bills. These mega-properties aren’t just residences — they’re real estate trophies with prices that reach into nine digits.

As a point of reference, the normal property tax on a typical one-family home in NYC is a fraction of that. But in luxury Manhattan apartment buildings, particularly along “Billionaires’ Row,” property values skyrocket – as do the levies.

Click here to learn more and subscribe to the newsletter

A Failing System? How The Majority Of NYC Homebuyers Pay Less

Notably, although such elite homes get massive media coverage, NYC’s system of property taxation is favorable to homeowners, particularly those who own residencies ranging from one to three units. These small residential homes are taxed at below 1% of their value, according to a Community Service Society/Progress and Poverty Institute study.

Concurrently, multifamily developments of 10 units or more are subject to a tax rate of nearly 4%. This is a burden placed on rental building landlords, not on individual homeowners.

This disparity leads to bigger questions, like:

1) Why is NYC’s property tax system still operating on a model from 50 years ago?

2) What does this mean for renters and low-income communities?

Get your free guide “Passive Real Estate Investing For Busy Professionals”

What’s New on Billionaires’ Row? What Happens When the Dream Lifestyle Falls Apart?

Luxury real estate continues booming in NYC. Even as other markets fluctuate, Manhattan’s high-end real estate continues to be a force to be reckoned with.

The newly signed contract at 111 West 57th Street is for a $56 million penthouse, a four-bedroom apartment in a supertall skyscraper co-developed by JDS Development, Property Markets Group, and Apollo. That’s $10 million down from its initial asking price.

Not long afterwards, another penthouse in the same tower became available for $110 million. This 11,500-square-foot, four-story “sky mansion” has five bedrooms, six baths, and expansive terraces overlooking the city.

And the market continues to be red-hot. Manhattan’s luxury home sales surged 30% in the fourth quarter compared with the same quarter last year, Douglas Elliman and Miller Samuel reported. The average sales price in the market’s top 10% was $10.3 million, a record high for the borough.

What happens when the dream lifestyle breaks down?

Sometimes those high-flying lifestyles come crashing down. Take former top real-estate broker Tal Alexander, who famously occupied 432 Park Avenue, a supertall that is the epitome of riches and success.

Alexander used to cite his home as evidence that he lived the same kind of life as the patrons whose interests he represented. But in 2024, after a brush with the law and money problems, his child and wife had to vacate the unit after being served a notice of nonpayment. Now, that erstwhile glamorous apartment is available for $55,000 per month.

A sober reminder that in New York City real estate, image can be everything until it isn’t.

Conclusion: How Will This Affect the Future of Real Estate in NYC?

From tax bills as high as the sky to court fights about fairness, New York’s property tax system has never faced such scrutiny. Luxury buyers are constantly making their moves, yet the debate about who is paying what – and why – is gaining momentum. What’s coming next? Will the city rewrite its antiquated tax code?

 Will litigation redesign the way in which NYC’s $100 billion budget is funded? And how much longer can the ultraluxury market just keep on rising before it peaks? One thing’s certain: whether you’re purchasing a penthouse or a brownstone, real estate in NYC is never just about the square footage — it’s a symbol of power, privilege, and policy.

Share this: